Friday, February 19, 2016

What did Pope Francis actually say about Trump and the border?

What did Pope Francis actually say?
“A person who thinks only about building walls, wherever they may be, and not building bridges, is not Christian. This is not in the Gospel,” the Pope said Feb. 18.

Pope Francis was asked to respond to comments from Donald Trump, who had referred to the Pope as a “pawn” for the Mexican government. Trump says that he will build a wall along the border of the United States and Mexico to prevent undocumented immigrants from entering the U.S.

TRUMP: Pope Francis is a very bad guy. He's a very nasty guy. Who does the Pope think he is saying I am not one of those Christians? After all, my mother gave me a Bible and its very dear to me. Isn't that what you Christians say?

BLADE: The Pope didn't say you weren't a Christian. First, he was responding to one of your unsolicited attacks and insults against him. And it was your rhetoric which he characterized as not Christian. He used the word 'only,' which in this case means 'exclusively'. Maybe if you'd explain your real position to the Pope in which you are in favor of "touch back" immigration, which is really just another form of amnesty...
http://hotair.com/archives/2016/01/22/cruz-trumps-for-amnesty-you-know/

TRUMP: I've never ever met a person that lies more than the Pope. One of the ways I can fight back is to bring a lawsuit against him... Even highly respected Senator, Tom Coburn, said Pope Francis was one of the most dishonest Popes he has ever seen. This, I can tell you.

COBURN: Uhhhh... That's another absolute fabrication. I’ve never said that about the Pope, period.

TRUMP: Pope Francis has pathological disease with no cure. He has a wall around the Vatican. A wall, people! Yet he would deny us a wall?

THE END

We interrupt this fake interview with Donald Trump to bring you these words from the Chattering Teeth Blogmaster.

This is for all you Trump sycophants, apologists and  toady lickspittles who are quick to miss characterize this Pope and what he actually says, and who have posted pictures of the Vatican wall - as if this proves somehow that the Pope is a hypocrite. 

I am no fan of open borders. I am an advocate for controlling the border, just as the Vatican controls their own. However, in any contest between Trump and the Pope, I'm siding with the Holy See. The underlying charge is self evident to anyone paying attention. Donald Trump is just as Christian as Obama.

Full disclosure - Those hateful words I put in Trump's circular piehole above are actual quotes he has used against Ted Cruz and Dr Ben Carson, both honorable men. But Trump's M.O. is to attack and to disparage in the press and on twitter, anyone who dares defy the great Donald.

So ask yourself just who it is criticizing the Vicar of Christ for celebrating Mass at the border because he thinks it 'political'?

TRUMP: I’m very capable of changing to anything I want to change to.


We know.

"It may come as a surprise to detractors of the Catholic position on immigration, but the Catholic Church acknowledges and supports the right of nations to control their borders and to enforce their laws. Indeed, enforcement is a key ingredient of a sound immigration policy, so long as it includes due process protections and safeguards human dignity."

5 comments:

Ed Bonderenka said...

Donald Trump is just as Christian as Obama.
Well of course!
After all, my mother gave me a Bible and its very dear to me. Isn't that what you Christians say?
Yeah. Like we say Two Corinthians.

Always On Watch said...

IMO, the Pope might have better phrased his comment thusly:

"Building walls, wherever they may be, and not building bridges, is not Christian. This is not in the Gospel."

Everything in this election cycle seems to promote more and more ad hominem attacks. I'm sick, sick, sick of all this -- and tuning out "the news" as much as possible.

Ed Bonderenka said...

I have many Catholic friends like Jerry.
Many as "born again" as I consider myself, but staying in the religion as my mom did.
And many former Catholic friends like Scherie and most of our family members who serve Christ outside of Catholicism.
I want to steer clear of attacking someone's religion while affirming that it is one's faith in Christ and not a religion that leads to salvation.

DaBlade said...

Ed, exactly right on both comments. Thank you, my brother in Christ. I feel exactly the same. I told my wife at dinner tonight that the one sure way to get me to circle the wagons around the Pope is for the main stream to attack him. Christians don't attack one another. My goodness, we have more than our fair share of real enemies.

AOW, I know that feeling. I I have mostly tuned out from tv news for that reason. I don't blog to tick anyone off, but sometimes I have to get stuff off my chest as an outlet. I think I will look for something silly to get back on track :)

Always On Watch said...

Ed,
it is one's faith in Christ and not a religion that leads to salvation

Exactly!